January 17, 2017
Soka University, Peace Research Institute
How can political science and international relations theories elucidate the ambiguity and complexity of Japan’s security identity? This paper offers a theoretical analysis of Japan’s vague security identity through the lens of analytical eclecticism as suggested by Peter Katzenstein in 2008. The reason this research employs analytical eclecticism is because it reconfirms that existing theories of orthodox international politics (classical/neo-liberalism and classical/neo-realism) and existing alternative approaches (constructivism) are incomplete in themselves, but are mutually supplemental within an eclectic research method. In an attempt to prove the applicability of analytical eclecticism and to investigate Japan’s changing security identity, this paper proposes four theoretical models of Japan’s security identity (a pacifist state, a UN peacekeeper, a normal state, and a US ally). By substantiating the validity of analytical eclecticism and visualising Japan’s elusive security identity, this paper attempts to make a contribution to the study of Japanese politics and to the application of international relations theory.
Keywords: analytical eclecticism, Article 9, Japan’s security identity, SDF.
Abe, Kohki, Satoshi Ukai and Hiroshi Morisu (2006)Sensō no Kokufuku (Overcome War), Tokyo: Shūeisha.
Akaha, Tsuneo (1993) ‘Japan’s Security Policy in the Posthegemonic World: Opportunities and Challenges’, in Tsuneo Akaha and Frank Langdon (eds)Japan in the Posthegemonic World, London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Berger, Thomas U. (1993) ‘From Sword to Chrysanthemum: Japan’s Culture of Anti-militarism’,International Security, 17 (4): 119-150.
——— (1998)Culture of Antimilitarism: National Security in Germany and Japan, Baltimore MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
——— (2007) ‘The Pragmatic Liberalism of an Adaptive State’, in Thomas U. Berger, Mike M. Mochizuki and Jitsuo Tsuchiyama (eds)Japan in International Politics: The Foreign Policies of an Adaptive State, London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Beyer, Vicki L. (1993) ‘The Hyakuri Base Case: Article 9 of the Constitution and the Public Law/Private Law Dichotomy in Japan’,Japanese Studies, 13 (3): 4-19.
Bull, Hedley (2002)The Anarchical Society: A Study of Order in World Politics, 3rd ed. New York: Palgrave.
Calder, Kent E. (1988) ‘Japanese Foreign Economic Policy Formation: Explaining the Reactive State’,World Politics, 40 (4): 517-541.
Carr, Edward H. (1949)The Twenty Years' Crisis, 1919-1939,London: Macmillan & CO. LTD.
Catalinac, Amy L. (2007) ‘Identity Theory and Foreign Policy: Explaining Japan’s Responses to the 1991 Gulf War and the 2003 U.S. War in Iraq’,Politics and Policy, 35 (1): 58-100.
Commission of Human Security (2003)Human Security Now, New York,http://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/91BAEEDBA50C6907C1256D19006A9353-chs-security-may03.pdf(accessed 25 May 2016).
Dobson, Hugo (2003)Japan and United Nations Peacekeeping: New Pressures, New Responses, London: Routledge Curzon.
Dunne, Tim (2000) ‘Theories as Weapons: E. H. Carr and International Relations’, in Michael Cox (ed)E. H. Carr: A Critical Appraisal, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Dupont, Alan (2001) ‘Weakened Japan Faces Decline as a Global Power’,International Herald Tribune, 12 March, Paris.
——— (2004)Unsheathing the Samurai Sword: Japan’s Changing Security Policy, Double Bay, NSW: Lowy Institute for International Policy.
——— (2005) ‘The Schizophrenic Superpower’,The National Interest, 79, Spring.
East Asia Forum(2012) ‘China-Japan Tensions over Senkaku Purchase An Orchestrated Affair’, 17 September,http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2012/09/17/china-japan-tensions-over-senkaku-purchase-an-orchestrated-affair/(accessed 12 December 2012).
Envall, H. D. P. (2008) ‘Transforming Security Politics: Koizumi Jun’ichiro and the Gaullist Tradition in Japan’,Electronic Journal of Contemporary Japanese Studies, 20 July,http://www.japanesestudies.org.uk/articles/2008/Envall.html(accessed 18 June 2012).
Funabashi, Yōichi (2004) ‘Japan as Global Civilian Power’,Asahi.com, 21 December,http://www.asahi.com/column/funabashi/eng/TKY200412210163.html(accessed 17 March 2011).
George, Aurelia (1993) ‘Japan’s Participation in U. N. Peacekeeping Operations: Radical Departure or Predictable Response?’,Asian Survey, 33 (6): 560-575.
Ghali, Boutros B. (1992)An Agenda for Peace: Preventive Diplomacy, Peacemaking and Peace-keeping,http://www.unrol.org/files/A_47_277.pdf(last accessed 25 May 2016).
Gilpin, Robert (1981)War and Change in World Politics, Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
Green, Michael J. (1995)Arming Japan: Defence Production, Alliance Politics, and the Post War Search for Autonomy, New York: Colombia University Press.
Hardacre, Helen (2005) ‘Constitutional Revision and Japanese Religions’,Japanese Studies, 25 (3): 235-247.
Hatoyama, Yukio (1999) ‘New Liberal Kaikenron: Jieitai o Guntai to Mitomeyo (New Liberal Constitutional Revision: Recognise the SDF as Army)’,Bungei Shunjū, October,http://nippon.zaidan.info/seikabutsu/2002/01252/contents/534.htm(accessed 24 August 2009).
——— (2009) ‘Kenpō Kaisei Shian no Chūkan Hōkoku: ‘Kokusai Kyōchō oyobi Heiwa Shugi’ ‘Anzen Hoshō’ no Jōkō ni tsuite (Midterm Report on Tentative Plan of Constitutional Revision: Articles on ‘International Cooperation and Pacifism’ and ‘Security’)’,Yukio Hatoyama Official Homepage,http://www.hatoyama.gr.jp/tentative_plan/shian1.doc(accessed 24 August 2009).
Hiraoka, Takashi (1996)Kibō no Hiroshima: Shichō wa Uttaeru (Hiroshima as Hope: Appeal by the Mayor), Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
Hobbes, Thomas (1962)Leviathan, John Plamenatz (ed), London: William Collins.
Hughes, Christopher W. (2004)Japan’s Re-Emergence as a ‘Normal’ Military Power?, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hook, Glenn D. (1996)Militarization and Demilitarization in Contemporary Japan, London: Routledge.
Inoguchi, Takashi (1991) ‘Japan's Response to the Gulf Crisis: An Analytic Overview’,Journal of Japanese Studies, 17 (2): 257-273.
——— (2008) ‘Japan as a Global Ordinary Power: Its Current Phase’,Japanese Studies, 28 (1): 3-13.
Inoue, Tatsuo (2006) ‘Kyūjō Sakujoron: Kenpō Rongi no Giman o Tatsu (Deletion of Article 9: Ending the Deception of the Constitutional Revision Debate)’, inRonza,Liberal karano Hangeki: Asia, Yasukuni, Kyūjō (Counterattack from Liberals: Asia, Yasukuni and Article 9), Tokyo: Asahi Shimbunsha.
INSS (Institute for National Strategic Studies, National Defense University) (2000)INSS Special Report (Armitage Report): The United States and Japan: Advancing Towards a Mature Partnership,http://www.ne.jp/asahi/nozaki/peace/data/data_inss_sr.html(last accessed 25 May 2016).
Ishihara, Shintarō (1989)The Japan That Can Say No, New York: Simon and Schuster.
Ishizuka, Katsumi (2008)Kokuren PKO to Heiwa Kōchiku: Kokusai Shakai niokeru Higashi Timōru eno Taiō (UNPKO and Peacebuilding: Measures of International Society against East Timor), Tokyo: Sōseisha.
ISS (Institute for Strategic Studies) (2009)Military Balance, London: Routledge.
Itō, Gō (2007) ‘Participation in UN Peacekeeping Operations’, in Thomas U. Berger, Mike M. Mochizuki and Jitsuo Tsuchiyama (eds)Japan in International Politics: The Foreign Policies of an Adaptive State, London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Johnson, Chalmers (2004)Teikoku America to Nihon Buryoku Izon no Kōzō (The US Empire and the Structure of Japan’s Military Dependence), Tokyo: Shūeisha.
Kahn, Herman (1970)The Emerging Japanese Superstate: Challenge and Response, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Kant, Immanuel (1939)Perpetual Peace, New York: Columbia University Press.
Katzenstein, Peter J. and Nobuo Okawara (1993)Japan’s National Security: Structures, Norms and Policy Responses in a Changing World, Ithaca, New York: East Asia Program, Cornell University.
Katzenstein, Peter J. (1996)Cultural Norms and National Security: Police and Military in Postwar Japan, London: Cornell University Press.
——— (2008)Rethinking Japanese Security: International and External Dimensions, New York: Routledge.
Keddell, Joseph P. (1993)The Politics of Defense in Japan: Managing Internal and External Pressures, London: M E Sharp.
Kegley, Charles W. Jr. and Eugene R. Wittkopf (2006)World Politics: Trend and Transformation, 10th ed, Melbourne: Thomson Wadsworth.
Keohane, Robert O. and Joseph Nye Jr. (1977)Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition, Boston: Little Brown.
Keohane, Robert O. (1984)After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy, Oxford: Princeton University Press.
Kimijima, Akihiko (2003) ‘‘Futsū no Kindai Kokka’ o Koeru Project toshiteno Nihonkoku Kenpō (The Japanese Constitution as a Project to Overcome ‘Normal Modern State’)’, in Johan Galtung and Akifumi Fujita (eds)Galtung Heiwagaku Nyūmon (Introduction to Galtung’s Theory of Peace: Grasping Peace for the 21st Century), Kyoto: Hōritsu Bunkasha.
Koizumi, Jun’ichirō (2003) ‘Statement on the Diet’s Approval, on July 26 2003, of Sending SDF to Iraq’,International Debates, 1 (6): 172-176.
Krasner, Stephen D. ed. (1983)International Regimes, Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
LDP (Liberal Democratic Party) Homepage (2009)https://www.jimin.jp/english/about-ldp/index.html(accessed 25 May 2016).
Lind, Jennifer M. (2004) ‘Pacifism or Passing the Buck?: Testing Theories of Japanese Security Policy’,International Security, 29 (1): 92-121.
Llewelyn, James, David Walton and Gen Kikkawa (2009)A Pacifist State in a Hostile Region: Japan and Post-War Conflict in Southeast Asia, New York: Nova Science Publishers.
McCormack, Gavan (2007)Client State: Japan in the American Embrace, London: Verso.
Middlebrooks, William C. Jr. (2008)Beyond Pacifism: Why Japan Must Become a ‘Normal’ Nation, Westport Conn: Praeger Security International.
Midford, Paul (2003) ‘Japan's Response to Terror: Dispatching the SDF to the Arabian Sea’,Asian Survey, 43 (2): 329-351.
——— (2011)Rethinking Japanese Public Opinion and Security: From Pacifism to Realism?, Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
Miyata, Mitsuo (2004)Hibusō Kokumin Teikō no Shisō (Philosophy of Unarmed Citizens’ Resistance), Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
Morgenthau, Hans J. (2006)Politics Among Nations: the Struggle for Power and Peace, Boston: McGraw-Hill Higher Education.
Nakanishi, Terumasa ed. (2006)‘Nihon Kakubusō’ no Ronten: Kokka Sonritsu no Kiki o Ikinuku Michi (‘Japan’s Nuclear Armament’: The Way to Survive the Crisis of National Existence), Tokyo: PHP Kenkyōjo, 2006.
Nasu, Hitoshi (2004) ‘Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution Revisited in the Light of International Law’,ANJeL, Nr/, 18: 50-66.
NDL (National Diet Library),The Constitution of Japan,http://www.ndl.go.jp/constitution/e/etc/c01.html(accessed 17 May 2009).
NDL,Proceedings of the 90th Imperial Parliament Session, Lower House Plenary Session, 26 June 1946,http://teikokugikai-i.ndl.go.jp(last accessed 25 May 2016).
NDL,Proceedings of the 19th Diet Session, Upper House Plenary Session, 2 June 1954,http://kokkai.ndl.go.jp(last accessed 25 May 2016).
NDL,Proceedings of the 130th Diet Session, Lower House Plenary Session, 21 July 1994,hhttp://kokkai.ndl.go.jp(last accessed 25 May 2016).
O’Hanlon, Michael (2007) ‘A Defense Posture for Multilateral Security’, in Thomas U. Berger, Mike M. Mochizuki and Jitsuo Tsuchiyama (eds)Japan in International Politics: The Foreign Policies of an Adaptive State, London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Ohta, Hikari, and Shin’ichi Nakazawa (2006)Kenpō Kyūjō o Sekai Isan ni (Let’s Make Article 9 Become World Heritage), Tokyo: Shūeisha Shinsho.
Ōta, Kazuo (1992) ‘The Meaning of the Japanese Constitution’,Japanese Studies, 12 (3): 106-110.
Okagaki, Tomoko (2000) ‘Thomas Hobbes to Kokusai Seiji (International Thought of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbery)’,Kokusai Seiji (International Relations), 124: 64-88.
Oros, Andrew L. (2008)Normalizing Japan: Politics, Identity, and the Evolution of Security Practice, Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
Ozawa, Ichirō (1994)Blueprint for a New Japan: The Rethinking of a Nation, Translated by Lousia Rubinfien and edited by Eric Gower, Tokyo: Kōdansha International.
——— (1999) ‘Nihon Koku Kenpō Kaisei Shian (Tentative Plan for Revision of the Japanese Constitution)’,Bungei Shunjū, September Special Edition,http://www.ozawa-ichiro.jp/policy/04.htm(accessed 6 August 2009).
——— (2006)Ozawa-Shugi: Kokorozashi o Mote Nihonjin (Ozawa-ism: Japanese Be Ambitious), Tokyo: Shūeisha International.
Paris, Roland (2004)At War’s End: Building Peace after Civil Conflict, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pugh, Michael (2004) ‘Peacekeeping and Critical Theory’,International Peacekeeping, 11 (1): 19-34.
Pyle, Kenneth B. (2007)Japan Rising: the Resurgence of Japanese Power and Purpose, New York: A Century Foundation Book, PublicAffairs.
Rich, Paul (2000) ‘E. H. Carr and the Quest for Moral Revolution in International Relations’, in Michael Cox (ed)E. H. Carr: A Critical Appraisal, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Russett, Bruce (1993)Grasping the Democratic Peace: Principles for a Post-Cold War World, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Samuels, Richard J. (1994)Rich Nation Strong Army: National Security and the Technological Transformation of Japan, London: Cornell University Press.
——— (2007) ‘Securing Japan: The Current Discourse’,Journal of Japanese Studies, 33 (1): 125-152.
Shinoda, Tomohito (2007a)Koizumi Diplomacy: Japan’s Kantei Approach to Foreign and Defense Affairs, London: University of Washington Press.
——— (2007b) ‘Becoming More Realistic in the Post-Cold War: Japan’s Changing Media and Public Opinion on National Security’,Japanese Journal of Political Science, 8 (2): 171-190.
Soeya, Yoshihide (1998) ‘Japan: ‘Normative Constraints Versus Structural Imperatives’’, in Muthiah Alagappa (ed)Asian Security Practice: Material and Ideational influences, Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
——— (2011)Japan as a ‘Normal Country’?: A Country in Search of its Place in the World, Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Tsuchiyama, Jitsuo (2000) ‘Realism no Saikōchiku wa Kanō ka: Thucydides to Gendai Kokusai Seijigaku (Is the Reconstruction of Realism Possible?: Thucydides and Contemporary International Politics)’,Kokusai Seiji (International Relations), 124: 45-63.
——— (2007) ‘War Renunciation, Article 9, and Security Policy’, in Thomas U. Berger, Mike M. Mochizuki and Jitsuo Tsuchiyama (eds)Japan in International Politics: The Foreign Policies of an Adaptive State, London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
United Nations,The Charter of the United Nations,http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter(last accessed 25 May 2016).
Waltz, Kenneth (2001)Men, the State and War: A Theoretical Analysis, New York: Colombia University Press.
——— (1979)Theory of International Politics, New York: McGraw Hill.
——— (1993) ‘The Emerging Structure of International Politics’,International Security, 18 (2): 44-79.
Weeks, Donna (2004) ‘Softly, softly to Iraq: Removing the Inverted Commas from Japan’s Security Contributions’,Australian Journal of International Affairs, 58 (4): 446-463.
Wendt, Alexander (1992) ‘Anarchy is What States Make of It: the Social Construction of Power Politics’,International Organization, 46 (2): 391-425.
——— (1999)Social Theory of International Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
William, Heinrich L. Jr. (1997)Seeking An Honored Place: The Japanese Self-Defense Forces and the Use of Armed Force Abroad, PhD Thesis submitted to Columbia University, New York: Columbia University.
About the Author
Authoris the Assistant Professor at the Soka University Peace Research Institute in Japan. He holds a PhD (Asian Studies and International Relations) from the University of Western Sydney, an MA (Peace and Conflict Studies) from the University of Sydney, and a BA (Humanities) from the Soka University Japan. His research interests include Japan’s pacifism and security policy, Japan-Australia relations, international peacekeeping operations, and nuclear disarmament.